So I decided to start small with my first Max on Musics, with just a run through of this little song by Barenaked Ladies, my favorite band ever. Just to get this out of the way, yes, my favorite band is the band that did the 'Chickity China' song as you peons call them, and yes, I think they're better than the Beatles, and pretty much any band ever. You know who else thinks so? PAUL FUCKING MCCARTNEY. That's right. Paul McCartney said his favorite band is the band that did the: "I just made you say underwear" song. And for good reason, unlike some other crazy things Sir Paul believes, like that PETA isn't crazy. Barenaked Ladies, since they were just Ed Robertson and Steven Page in their parent's basement recording cassettes, have demonstrated scary lyrical and compositional skills, and continue to to this day.
Most people remember them for their quirky, goofy songs like "One Week" and "If I Had A Million Dollars", but to really understand the depth of their talent, you need to listen to more Tonight is the Night I Fell Asleep at The Wheels and For Yous and Straw Hat and Old Dirty Hanks. It's sort of like people remembering Warren Zevon for Werewolves of London, and not French Inhaler or Carmelita.....Or The Beatles for I Want to Hold Your Hand and not Strawberry Fields..you get the idea. Barenaked Ladies have a lot of amazing songs. The one I'm singing today is among them.
Download my performance of I Can I Will I Do by clicking here:
http://kiwi6.com/file/1fo4896km2
INSTRUCTIONS: Don't click anything that says download except for the blue text in the yellow box that says: Download File 4.37 MB. NOT the green thing that says download now, and not the blue button that says download. Just the blue text in the yellow box. I'm sorry for the not so user friendly shit, once I find a better way to file host I'll do that.
....
"Friend, this shouldn't be the way things end
But then, a break is just around the bend.
And when you tell me as I leave
You're scared you'll never see my face again
Well, I'm not sure it's the truth
You don't think I can love you
You don't think I can love you
You don't think I can love you
But I can and I will and I do
You write - I read your letters every night
All right, I skim them just to be polite.
I fight embarrassment and shame
The mention of your name makes me turn white
But guilt still makes me refrain
You don't think I can love you
You don't think I can love you
You don't think I can love you
But I can and I will and I do
I imagine you think I don't think of you
You know you couldn't be more wrong
If good intentions paved the road that gets me through
Then I've got a six-lane highway
And I intend to someday
Do all the things I say I can and I will and I do
Hey - it's hard for me to go away
Okay, I know it's not adult
But it's just as difficult for me to stay
And anyway you say
You don't think I can love you
You don't think I can love you
You don't think I can love you
love you
love you
love you
I can and I will and I do
I can and I will and I do"
-From "I Can I Will I Do", written by Steven Page and Ed Robertson
Performed by Barenaked Ladies
What I especially love about the writing style of Steven and Ed, is how much they say with so few words, and mislead you into believing the song is about something it isn't, and turning this misconception on you.
"You don't think I can love you, but:
I can
and I will
and I do"
Just listening to these words, Steven and Ed set up our narrator, desperately trying to convince the 'you' of this song, (let's just assume it's a girl he's in a relationship for expediency's sake, many other interpretations can be had that I ), that in spite of what she's seeing, he in fact loves her and that she shouldn't break it off with him (hint hint, or perhaps she shouldn't be the one breaking it off because he wants to), because her beliefs are unfounded.
But if you really look deep into it, you see he's full of shit. When he talks about what he actually does, as opposed to intends to do, we see that he only skims her letters, and that he internally struggles with and feels guilt and embarrassment about what he does to her. In the end, his reasons for fighting to stay with her are revealed, it's just as hard for him to leave her as it is for him to stay with her, so he chooses to do neither and be wishy washy not really there for her, not committed, but not leaving. The contradictions of what he's trying to convince her that he feels and what truly lies inside of him become obvious, and it fleshes out the story and characters farther than what it seems like on the surface. It's like one day you were passing by this couple arguing, and you hear this guy, his voice breaking and saying some things that strike true with you, but when you think about something he's said deeper and discover a giant hole in his logic, you think: "Wait...He's full of shit! That guy was an asshole!"
That's a lot like my relationship with this song, for a while I sang it in my head, I thinking it's sweet and about heartbreak, and didn't give it much thought until all of a sudden something clicked and I stared off into the distance as I started to understand the song on a deeper level. When that happened, I connected it with personal experiences I've had of someone doing the same thing to me, deeply trying to convince me that everything will be alright and appealing to my emotional side that they intend to someday, do all the things they say, and stop living in their intentions. Mistaking the words of 'can' and 'will', the ability to and planning to with 'do', actually doing it. If they've convinces you...then you've let someone off the hook who hasn't proven themselves, and more than likely will not.
Singing this song was fun, but challenging. I was definitely attempting to channel the way Steven Page sang this on BNL's White Album: Barenaked Ladies Are Men, and he chose to sing it in a different style than he does with most songs. The guy is one of the greatest singers of all time, his voice is powerful with a capital owerful. Just look up Break Your Heart or Call and Answer and you'll see this guy's got some serious pipes, and can belt like a motherfucker. But on the recording of I Can I Will I Do, his voice is hoarse, and restraining the strength we know he has, and his voice gets high just to the point of breaking, and the strong guitar riff hanging above all of the other instruments contrasts the performance style. The guy sounds broken, and it makes us empathize with him immediately, very important in understanding the true meaning of the song. In the end it shows us how weak the character truly is.
I'm not used to singing like this, I'm more used to needing power to stand over a guitar or other instruments, so attempting this live without the vocal levels way higher than the instruments would result in the lyrics being drowned out. Luckily I had garage band, and one taked it with some background sounds from my cat playing with a battery, most of which I cut out. I apologize for whatever I couldn't cut out, next time I'll be better. I hope you enjoyed this new section I'm doing, comment/email if you have any future suggestions for it.....and more coming soon! Essays! Moar International Coffee Day! Book Excerpts? Maybe! WE'LL SEE. WE'LL ALL SEE.
EDIT: Something I didn't add that was cool about the song: When he says "Guilt still makes me refrain-", he's transitioning to the actual refrain of the song, while talking about how literally his guilt makes him refrain. Just a little thing I thought was really goddamn cool. Another example of how clever these ladies are.